Case Study
PSYC FPX 4900 Assessment 2 An Ethical Analysis of a Case Study The case study is about the student and guidance counselor of Riverbend City High School. The guidance counselor Hannah was a 36-year-old African American while the student Adara was a 15-year-old Muslim American. Adara was feeling alone and insecure because she was the only Muslim American and she was continuously bullied in school and online due to her appearances. Due to this issue, she feels safe to talk to Hannah and ask for her help to tackle confidently the bullying and situations that make her insecure. Despite the safety, she feels while talking to Hannah she was not sure if it would be right and acceptable to seek help outside of the school without the permission of her parents. During the counseling session with Hannah, Adara shared thoughts of harming herself in situations where she was being bullied and made fun of because of her appearance. Understanding the seriousness of the matter Hannah informed Adara’s parents about her current mental health which ultimately led to breaking the trust of Adara. Adara trusted Hannah for her challenges and opened herself up to ask for help for the improvement of her mental health.
Ethical Issues and Principles
Considering the situation of Hannah and Adara a question arises about how Hannah is going to handle the situation with effectivity and sensitivity to ensure no one gets hurt and the matter gets resolved. She needs to take careful measures to understand the bullying, cultural diversities, and insecurities of Adara to ensure the success of the results (Mbah, 2020). Major guidelines and principles about maintaining a positive environment in schools and ensuring the consideration of the ethical concerns of the people were given by the American School Counselor Association (ASCA) and American Psychological Association (APA). Bullying is a most common ethical issue in schools which in some cases leads to the disturbance of the environment of the school and creates negativity among the students. In this assessment, the provided guidelines will be used to identify specific ethical principles necessary for the elimination of bullying from the school using a proper process of reporting and then eliminating it (Abayomi & Daniels, 2021). It will also define ways to educate people about handling this kind of situation with care and sensitivity for the betterment of society.
Applied Ethical Principles and Standards
General Principle E
To carefully handle the case of Adara two key principles were given by APA which ensure that she will recover as soon as possible from the thoughts of self-harm and lead a life of confidence and equality in society. The principles are based on the consideration of the ethical rights of the clients taking sessions from their psychologist for the betterment of their mental situation (Eirik Bjørge, 2023). The first key principle of APA is the General Principle E according to which the counselor or the psychologist should not be biased based on different factors like gender, color, age, or religion. This is necessary to protect the rights of the clients and ensure their dignity is not harmed. In the case of Adara, Hannah should have considered the cultural background of the student and provided sessions based on the consideration of her insecurities and fears. It is necessary to give confidence to Adara that her beliefs and concerns are respected and considered.
4.05 Disclosures
The other important principle is 4.05 disclosures which gives psychologists, caregivers, and counselors the right to share information that is needed with the relatives of the family members of the affected person to prevent any kind of harm and inform them about the seriousness of the situation. This will eventually help the parents and the child to collectively make efforts for the prevention of big harm (Younas & Gutman, 2022). However, in the case of Adara, Hannah informed her parents without fully understanding her cultural background, insecurities, and fears which led to the breakage of trust between both. Despite Hanah following the principle she needed to use a more appropriate and thoughtful approach to handle the situation of Adara. She should ensure that Adara is confident and feels supported for informing her parents which eventually keeps the trust and produces better results.
Serious and Foreseeable Harm to Self and Others
Furthermore, principle A.9 of ASCA states that the harm that seems dangerous and could impact others along with the client needs to be informed. In the case of Adara, Hannah informed her parents without taking her into confidence which ultimately led to mismanagement of the situation (Lewis et al., 2020). To handle this situation Hannah should understand the complete history of Adara including her cultural background, insecurities, fears, and reason behind the thought of self-harm. This way of handling the situation is against the principle of A.9 so while ensuring the ethical rights and dignity of others it is necessary to keep them in confidence regarding their information.
Alternative Solutions
In the case of Adara, Hannah could have considered different approaches to effectively understand the situation of Adara and implement strategies and methodologies that are helpful and keep her confident and supported. A few alternative solutions for the effective handling of the situation are given below;
- By allowing Adara to write a report of each bullying incident and document it for the immediate resolution of the bullying problem.
- Programs need to be initiated for the students and teachers of the school regarding the prevention of bullying.
- Increasing awareness among people and educating them about ethical principles will help them maintain a positive school environment.
- Hannah should consider sharing the problem with her colleagues for a better approach to disclosure and to keep the trust between the student and teacher.
- Effective and advanced training should be given to the school staff to ensure they are well aware of the principles and guidelines needed to ensure the ethical rights of the people and students.
- The mental helath professionals should be invited to teh school for a better analysis of the student’s concerns and the education of the staff members.
Research Findings
handling bullying situations with care and sensitivity is necessary to ensure that the root cause of bullying is identified and effectively tackled (Özer & Escartín, 2023). The better handling of the situation ensures that the root cause of the problem has been identified and effectively managed for the accuracy of the results. Moreover, proper awareness about bullying and providing counseling to the bullies and victims will help in the elimination of this habit from the school and maintain a positive school environment. Ensuring support to both groups will help in the elimination of bullying and incraesing a friendly environment. Another effective approach for the timely handling of cyberbullying is to take action as soon as possible to prevent harm (Nguyen et al., 2022). Despite all the effective approaches a problem occurs when the school counselor is overworked and unable to give full attention to the details which leads to the mismanagement of the situation. However, this problem can be resolved by hiring more staff to ensure that the mental health of the students is balanced and strong.
Conclusion
The case study is about a 15-year-old student Adara and a school counselor Hannah. Adara was Muslim American and she was bullied online and in school for her appearances as she was the minority taht is only Muslim American. Adara shared with Hannah her thoughts of self-harm and Hannah informed her parents about her thoughts (Da’as, 2023). This act of Hannah creates a feeling of mistrust between both leading to the breaking of confidence of Adara. A few organizations provide guidelines and principles for the management of bullying cases effectively in the school. According to 4.05 disclosures Hannah should take Adara into confidence by fully understanding her cultural background for the better management of the situation.
References
Abayomi, W., & Daniels, A. (2021). Creating awareness of bullying, its impact on children, and strategies towards behavioural change. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 09(11), 363–394. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2021.911026
Bjørge, E. (2023). General principles of law formed within the international legal system. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 72(4), 845–867. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0020589323000362
Da’as, R. (2023). Role of ethical school leadership in shaping adolescents’ aggressive attitudes: A doubly latent multilevel SEM analysis. Educational Management Administration & Leadership. https://doi.org/10.1177/17411432231216580
Lewis, T., Jones, K. D., Militello, M., & Meisenhelder, R. (2020). A clear and consistent focus on students: principals’ perceptions of the role of school counselors. Journal of School Leadership, 32(1), 105268462097206. https://doi.org/10.1177/1052684620972067
Mbah, R. (2020). Running head: Effects of bullying on students’ academic performance i the perception of students about school bullying and how it affects academic performance in cameroon. https://research.library.mun.ca/14613/1/thesis.pdf
Nguyen, A., Ngo, H. N., Hong, Y., Dang, B., & Nguyen, B. (2022). Ethical principles for artificial intelligence in education. Education and Information Technologies, 28(28). https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10639-022-11316-w
Özer, G., & Escartín, J. (2023). The making and breaking of workplace bullying perpetration: A systematic review on the antecedents, moderators, mediators, outcomes of perpetration and suggestions for organizations. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 69, 101823. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2023.101823
Younas, F., & Gutman, L. M. (2022). Parental risk and protective factors in child maltreatment: A systematic review of the evidence. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 24(5), 3697–3714. https://doi.org/10.1177/15248380221134634