Introduction
DB FPX 8710 Assessment 3 Kensington Auto Parts has been experiencing declining financial trends in the last year, and this has contributed to the identification of the business problem of leadership failures. The paper will outline frameworks and trace them to the business issue in the following.
Specific Business Problem and Gap in Process
Kensington Auto made a loss in the last year. There were a number of factors responsible for the loss and due to this, it is necessary to know the real problem in order to turn around the trend of losing market share. Examination of the business case shows that the fundamental business issue is the breakdown of leadership. Kensington Perry, CEO, understood that there were no necessary strategies in leadership in order to thrive. Following the identified particular business issue, the next step is to delve deeper to identify the practice gap that led to the problem. For Kensington Auto Parts, the CEO had recognized that his organization did not have the tools to implement the strategies that would enable them to become successful. Leadership is the actual practice gap. Leadership starts at the top, and therefore Mr. Perry lacked the leadership skills necessary for providing his team with the tools and strategies for the success of the company. That eventually led to the downfall of market shares.
Frameworks
Frameworks are used in the business world to organize and condense a company’s objectives and process (Magloff, 2021). Usually, such frameworks are consulted at times when a company is under duress. Kensington Auto Parts’ case is one instance of frameworks having to be updated. Finding frameworks that outline evidence of leadership breakdowns at Kensington Auto is a critical step towards repairing the business problem. Frameworks are most beneficial when analysis is done well. The following frameworks will follow analysis and benefits of each of them
Scholarly Framework
Ishikawa diagrams or Fishbone diagrams find common use in business among leadership teams in order to discuss the possible causes for a business issue and what can be done about them (Sharmila Reddy, 2019).By creating such a diagram, the cause and effect of the business problem will be discussed in order to facilitate management in providing a solution. The Fishbone Analysis model is the scholarly model that best fits Kensington Auto Parts. The Fishbone Analysis model can be applied to Kensington Auto Parts since it identifies the root cause of the problem, and it provides evidence to the executive leadership team that there are failures in leadership and development within the organization that is accountable for the loss of market shares over the past year. Sketching a fishbone diagram to present cause and effect is the heart of the Fishbone Analysis structure.
Practitioner Framework
The ideal practitioner model to implement to this company problem is the Congruence Framework.
David A. Nadler and Michael L. Tushman (Sridharan, 2022), organizational scholars, have designed the Congruence Framework. Through it, one gets to ascertain the root causes of issues of organizational performance. The Congruence Framework gives a system view of change needed. In Kensington Auto’s scenario, this framework would be most applicable as it would allow the executive leadership team to view inputs and outputs of the company. This gives a clear idea of what change is needed for the company to become profitable once again. This framework involves the examination of inputs and outputs, which leads to a more extended process but one that is thorough
Framework Justification
Congruence Framework
The Congruence Framework provides an opportunity for Mr. Kensington to clarify the inputs and outputs of the organization to see the areas that are weak.Using this framework provides a superb diagnostic for the problems at hand. The only disadvantage of this framework is there is typically a requirement for additional tools to support the whole change. Kensington Auto Parts would need an additional framework structure to complete the whole analysis to create the positive improvements needed to return to profitability.
Fishbone Analysis Framework
DB FPX 8710 Assessment 3 Fishbone Analysis framework is another tool that supports the Congruence Framework as it will show cause and effect of the company. By identifying the cause and effect of the business problem, it allows Mr. Kensington to evaluate where his leadership failed and how that impacted the remainder of the leadership team and consequently the company. Placing a Figure of the Pain Points
This will, in turn, facilitate a clear realization of what needs to change and who will need to be affected by the changes. It is crucial that the interventions introduced be susceptible to rigorous review so that they help towards the restoration of profitability for the return at Kensington Auto Parts. Replacing market shares to profitability is key to the company, as this will ensure that it stands the test of time.
Framework and Current Trends in Strategy and Innovation
Investigation of outdated or new business models and utilizing them as a tool to build new, innovative business models in order to develop success within a company is an existing trend (Lüttgens & Diener, 2016).
Different business models are ranked in terms of the impact they hold. The model used is Porter’s forces in order to compare different business models and rank them accordingly. With the framework of Porter’s forces, firms are analyzing other business models and schemes in order to come up with more creative strategies for their success. Being able to contrast good and bad business models and methods provides an opportunity to come up with an innovative strategy by putting all the successful aspects together to create a unique model.
Related Business Problem
The majority of firms are attempting to restructure their business model to fit the changes that the pandemic has caused. It has been a common business challenge since 2019 when the COVID-19 pandemic halted most businesses. Shifts in society such as consumer behavior have changed the paradigm of every business. Online shopping has become the means of shopping for most Americans, providing businesses with spaces of new innovation and strategy. This business problem would be assisted by the Fishbone Analysis model as well as the Congruence Model. The firms would be able to analyze where the organization was weakest during the pandemic. There, the weaknesses would be articulated, which would result in solutions to strengthen the organization in case of any other unexpected events.
Reflection
I have acquired the knowledge by going through this analysis on how to not just detect a business problem, but its cause also.By using numerous frameworks, changes required to remedy the business issue and bridge the gap in procedure can be known.The change mechanisms have to be reviewed to examine how effective they are so changes will bear results. This course and assessment have set the groundwork for me in my DBA journey and in my professional life. I have gained and mastered skills to implement in my current job. I diagnose systems and processes on a daily basis and develop and create improved plans for the purpose of achieving a smoother user experience. The research in this analysis can be applied in my daily work, leading to more innovative ideas which simplify things to use for our customers.
References
Cavaleri, S., & Shabana, K. (2018). Rethinking sustainability strategies. Journal of Strategy and Management, 11(1), 2–17.https://doi.org/10.1108/jsma-08-2016-0050
Filipović, S., Vasić, M., Tica, S., Veg, E., & Šiniković, G. (2020). Application of Modified Nadler-Tushman Model in GAP Analysis of Education Process of EFNMS Certified Engineer. Tehni
ki Vjesnik, 27(4), 1213–1220. https://doaj.org
Lüttgens, D., & Diener, K. (2016). Patterns of business models employed as an instrument for generating (new) innovative business models. Journal of Business Models, 4(3), 19-36
DB FPX 8710 Assessment 3 Aligning Frameworks
Magloff, L. (2021, December 7). What Is an Operational Framework in Business? Chron.com.https://smallbusiness.chron.com/operational-framework-business-25852.html
Sharmila Reddy. (2019, August 21). Fishbone Diagram (Meaning, Examples) | How to Draw an Ishikawa Diagram? Wallstreetmojo.com.https://www.wallstreetmojo.com/fishbone-diagram/
Sridharan, M. (2022, February 8). Nadler-Tushman Congruence Framework. Thinkinsights.net.https://thinkinsights.net/strategynadler-tushman-congruence-framework/